Home > Star Trek: The Next Generation
A Matter of Perspective
00:00:36Captain, we have arrived at Tanuga IV.
00:00:39The away team has completed its survey of Dr. Apgar's work and is ready to return to the ship.
00:00:45Good.
00:00:50Oh, please... and feel free to examine the work of the other students, too.
00:01:01Hmm...
00:01:02Ensign Williams' striking style is heavily influenced by geometric constructivism.
00:01:16Lieutenant Wright has effectively fused the incongruities of the surrealists with the irrationality of Dadaism.
00:01:35Interesting.
00:01:36Oh.
00:01:37Thank you.
00:01:39In what way?
00:01:41While suggesting the free treatment of form usually attributed to fauvism this quite inappropriately attempts to juxtapose the disparate cubistic styles of Picasso and Leger.
00:01:55In addition, the use of color suggests a haphazard melange of clashing styles.
00:02:01Furthermore, the unsettling overtones of proto-Vulcan influences...
00:02:04Thank you... Mr. Data.
00:02:06You are welcome, sir.
00:02:07If I can be of further assistance...
00:02:09No... thank you.
00:02:15( door opens and closes )
00:02:18Captain's Log, Stardate 43610.4:
00:02:22After completing a delivery of dicosilium
00:02:24to the Tanuga IV research station
00:02:26our away team has received an update from Dr. Nel Apgar
00:02:30on his efforts to create Krieger waves,
00:02:32a potentially valuable new power source.
00:02:35Welcome back, Mr. La Forge.
00:02:37Thank you, sir.
00:02:38Where's Commander Riker?
00:02:40He's still down on the station, sir.
00:02:42Dr. Apgar wanted to have a word with him.
00:02:44Any problems?
00:02:47Not with the scientific part of the mission, no, sir.
00:02:51Riker to Enterprise.
00:02:53I'm ready to leave now.
00:02:54I'm sure Commander Riker will be able to explain everything, Captain.
00:02:57O'BRIEN: Stand by, Commander.
00:02:58Engaging transport.
00:03:01( beeping )
00:03:02( machinery powering down )
00:03:04Transporter Room to Engineering.
00:03:06I have a power drain.
00:03:18Transporter Room.
00:03:19Is Commander Riker aboard?
00:03:21O'BRIEN: Not yet, Captain. I'm having trouble clearing the signal.
00:03:33Transporter Room to Bridge.
00:03:36He's aboard.
00:03:40Why do you sound so surprised, Mr. O'Brien?
00:03:42Well, for a moment, we weren't sure you left the space station in time.
00:03:46In time for what?
00:03:48It just exploded, sir.
00:04:23Space, the final frontier.
00:04:28These are the voyages of the Starship Enterprise.
00:04:32Its continuing mission--
00:04:34to explore strange new worlds...
00:04:38to seek out new life and new civilizations...
00:04:42to boldly go where no one has gone before.
00:05:46Captain's Log, supplemental:
00:05:48Commander Riker has informed me
00:05:50that Dr. Apgar was the only one aboard the space station
00:05:53when it exploded.
00:05:55We remain in orbit investigating the accident.
00:05:59I've gone through the whole system, Captain.
00:06:01I can't find any malfunction in the transporter or nothing that would cause an explosion like that.
00:06:07Why was there a power drain before transport?
00:06:09I don't know, sir.
00:06:11I shall want an answer to that.
00:06:12I'm sure the Tanugans will, too.
00:06:14Yes, sir.
00:06:15Captain, the radiation and debris are consistent with an overload of the station's reactor core.
00:06:20Were there any indications of reactor core problems while you were on the station?
00:06:25No, sir.
00:06:26Number One?
00:06:30Mr. La Forge indicated that this was not an entirely routine mission.
00:06:35It's a long story, sir but I'm sure it doesn't have anything to do with this accident.
00:06:40( communications beep )
00:06:42Captain, Chief Investigator Krag of the Tanugan security force requests permission to beam aboard.
00:06:47Granted. Will you escort him to the Bridge, Mr. Worf?
00:06:50WORF: Aye, sir.
00:06:53Perhaps you had better tell me as much as possible prior to his arrival, Number One.
00:07:01( sighing )
00:07:12I'm Lieutenant Worf, head of ship's security.
00:07:15I will take you to the Captain.
00:07:24Chief Investigator, welcome to the Enterprise.
00:07:28I'm Captain Picard.
00:07:30This is my First Officer
00:07:32Commander William Riker.
00:07:34Commander Riker, I am here to take you into custody.
00:07:38Custody? On what charge?
00:07:41Suspicion of murder.
00:07:42Murder? Now, wait a minute. You can't come on...
00:07:45Chief Investigator... we are perfectly willing to cooperate with you...
00:07:48Then release the prisoner for transportation to the planet.
00:07:55Let's continue this discussion in private.
00:08:00Number One, you have the Bridge.
00:08:25Just what is the evidence against my officer?
00:08:28Two witnesses have come forward to describe Commander Riker's threats against Dr. Apgar.
00:08:33Threats?
00:08:34I'm aware there was a private conversation between them.
00:08:37Apparently, it was much more than just a private conversation but he will be given a chance to prove his innocence.
00:08:43Investigator, in our system of jurisprudence, a man is innocent until proved guilty.
00:08:50In ours, he is guilty until he is proved innocent, and you are under our jurisdiction.
00:08:56If I understand Federation regulations on this matter, and I just happened to look them up...
00:09:02I am aware of Federation regulations, sir, and if you investigate them further you will find the Captain decides if extradition is warranted.
00:09:11Are you saying it is not?
00:09:12I am saying if there is sufficient cause to warrant a trial,
00:09:17I will release my officer into your custody.
00:09:21Would you say that you are close to your First Officer, Captain?
00:09:24That question is irrelevant here.
00:09:27Really, Captain, you cannot believe that.
00:09:29How can I expect a fair and impartial decision?
00:09:32I must protect the rights of my officer.
00:09:35I can appreciate that, but you will do it on the planet, not here.
00:09:41After all, what if you were suddenly to decide to leave this star system?
00:09:47You have my word as a Starfleet officer that I will not.
00:09:54Unacceptable.
00:09:55Captain, you will turn him over to me for interrogation now.
00:10:02Interrogate him here.
00:10:04We must re-create step by step, moment by moment, all the events leading to the explosion.
00:10:12We will require access to all the witnesses as well as the data from the lab's ground computers.
00:10:18It would be impossible to accomplish here.
00:10:21Perhaps not.
00:10:23Mr. Data, will you report to my ready room?
00:10:25DATA: Aye, sir.
00:10:27We may be able to assist you in re-creating these events.
00:10:33Commander Data, this is Chief Inspector Krag.
00:10:37Commander, by taking testimony from the away team and from witnesses provided by the Investigator, would it be possible to program the holodeck to re-create what happened on the science station?
00:10:49It would require construction and design specifications full orthographic representations of the Krieger equipment as well as visual representations and voice analyses of the persons involved, but it is possible.
00:11:05Very well.
00:11:07Arrangements will be made to provide you with all available information.
00:11:12I shall return shortly with our witnesses.
00:11:15Commander, will you escort Investigator Krag to Transporter Room Three?
00:11:35Ensign Crusher, Mr. La Forge... we are going to re-create the research station here on the holodeck.
00:11:41I want you to work with Commander Data on the preparations.
00:11:44In addition, Commander La Forge and Commander Riker,
00:11:48I want you to give the computer detailed depositions of everything you saw, everything you heard while you were on board.
00:11:54Counselor, I want you to assist me during this inquiry.
00:12:03My decision about the extradition will be based on the evidence presented during these re-creations.
00:12:14Captain...
00:12:17May I have a word with you?
00:12:19Under the circumstances, Number One,
00:12:22I think that would be inappropriate.
00:12:36DATA: Second Officer's Log, Stardate 43611.6:
00:12:41Programming of the holodeck has taken 18 hours, 11 minutes
00:12:45and is now complete.
00:12:47All participants have entered their depositions.
00:12:50Technical schematics and complete records
00:12:52from the lab's ground computers
00:12:54as well as Dr. Apgar's personal logs
00:12:56have been included.
00:12:57The re-creations will have
00:12:58a nominal 8.7% margin of error.
00:13:09( door begins closing )
00:13:27Is there anything you'd like to say before we begin, Number One?
00:13:31Just this.
00:13:33I'm not a murderer.
00:13:35I went to the Tanugan lab as an official representative of Starfleet.
00:13:39I acted accordingly.
00:13:40I was there to evaluate Dr. Apgar's progress in the development of a Krieger-wave converter.
00:13:47That's all I was interested in.
00:13:50Computer...
00:13:51( beeping )
00:13:52...load deposition program
00:13:54Riker One.
00:13:57Run the simulation.
00:14:05Dr. Apgar?
00:14:07I'm Commander William Riker.
00:14:08Lieutenant Commander Geordi La Forge.
00:14:10My assistant, Tayna.
00:14:12Well, let's get on with it, shall we?
00:14:15Let's not be in such a hurry, dear.
00:14:17Perhaps our guest would care for some refreshments?
00:14:21My wife, Manua.
00:14:23RIKER: A pleasure to meet you, Mrs. Apgar.
00:14:25If you're prepared to start, so are we.
00:14:27Of course, I'm prepared.
00:14:30All right. Why don't you give me an overview of your research while Mr. La Forge and your assistant take a look at the experimental data.
00:14:36Fine, whatever.
00:14:38I must say, Commander, I resent this early arrival.
00:14:41Starfleet will get its converter.
00:14:42I've had a few setbacks, that's all.
00:14:44We're not here to pressure you, Doctor.
00:14:47We just want an update on your progress.
00:14:48Tayna, show the Commander's assistant whatever he wants to see. Give him full access to our records.
00:14:53TAYNA: Yes, Doctor.
00:14:55If you'll come with me.
00:14:56Our lambda field generator is on the planet since it requires a minimum of 5,000 kilometers for the field to collimate.
00:15:03Really, darling, you're being rude.
00:15:05After all, Commander Riker is willing to sit through all your prattle about Krieger waves.
00:15:08Let's have a drink, Commander, and we'll hear all about Krieger waves.
00:15:23To your success, Doctor.
00:15:25Mm-hmm.
00:15:26And the rewards that come with it.
00:15:31Riker, what is Starfleet doing here anyway?
00:15:33My delivery wasn't scheduled for another three months.
00:15:35Well, we were in this sector on another mission, and since you had already contacted Starfleet about additional dicosilium, it seemed like a good opportunity.
00:15:43How interesting.
00:15:45Tell us about this other mission.
00:15:47It was just a study of a proto-star cloud.
00:15:49The Enterprise will be back tomorrow.
00:15:51The Enterprise just left you here?
00:15:54We didn't want to inconvenience you.
00:15:55We've made arrangements for quarters on the planet.
00:15:57Oh, I won't hear of such a thing.
00:15:59Commander, I insist you and Mr. La Forge stay with us.
00:16:02I hardly think...
00:16:04I know that you would prefer to be left alone with your very important work but I, for one, am glad for the company.
00:16:14Good.
00:16:17I must apologize for my husband's lack of social graces.
00:16:20He may be one of the great scientific minds in the galaxy, but... he does come up a bit short in other areas.
00:16:31KRAG: Wait a moment.
00:16:32Stop.
00:16:34Computer, freeze program.
00:16:36KRAG: Then it's your testimony that it was Mrs. Apgar's idea for you to spend the night aboard the space station?
00:16:43It's my testimony and it's the truth.
00:16:49Resume program.
00:16:54Our guest quarters aren't luxurious, but I've tried to make this room warm and inviting.
00:16:59I'll be very comfortable, thank you.
00:17:01Good night.
00:17:03The environmental controls are over here.
00:17:06I'm sure I'll find everything I need.
00:17:08And the door shuts by touching this panel.
00:17:14Mrs. Apgar...
00:17:16This is my sanctuary.
00:17:17Privacy is very important on a small station.
00:17:22I'm left alone here, often for hours.
00:17:27It's late.
00:17:28I am tired.
00:17:32Are you still tired, Commander?
00:17:34RIKER: Ma'am, excuse me.
00:17:36I really think that you ought to leave.
00:17:40I knew I'd find you with him.
00:17:41Did you think I didn't notice how you looked at him?
00:17:45I'm not the fool you take me for.
00:17:47RIKER: Doctor!
00:17:48( groaning )
00:17:51Doctor, believe me.
00:17:52This has been a terrible mistake.
00:17:54You won't get away with this.
00:17:56I'll see to it.
00:17:57I swear I will, Riker.
00:18:04Freeze program.
00:18:05I didn't see Dr. Apgar until the following morning when he asked to see me alone.
00:18:11Commander La Forge returned to the Enterprise.
00:18:14Resume program.
00:18:17I suppose if I make a formal complaint, your report on my work won't be very good.
00:18:22Doctor, this is going to have no impact on my report.
00:18:24It was a misunderstanding of the worst kind.
00:18:27We could straighten the entire thing out if you would ask Mrs. Apgar to join us.
00:18:31My wife and my assistant have transported down to the planet.
00:18:36What are you going to put in your report, Riker?
00:18:37That there is no justification for all the extra dicosilium I've requested?
00:18:41That is why they sent you early, isn't it?
00:18:44Doctor, I...
00:18:46NEL: I can explain why I needed it.
00:18:47They have no idea what my problems are.
00:18:49There are explanations for...
00:18:51I don't need explanations.
00:18:53Then we have nothing further to say to each other.
00:18:59I'll tell my Captain to expect your grievance.
00:19:02Do that.
00:19:07Riker to Enterprise.
00:19:09I'm ready to leave now.
00:19:11O'BRIEN: Stand by, Commander.
00:19:14Engaging transport.
00:19:17Freeze program.
00:19:19Then I returned to the Enterprise.
00:19:21And you have nothing further to add, Commander?
00:19:24Nothing about firing a phaser?
00:19:26I never fired a phaser on the science station.
00:19:30Well, that's odd... very odd.
00:19:33Captain Picard, is it not true that your sensors detected an energy drain just as Commander Riker began transport?
00:19:41That's correct.
00:19:42KRAG: Have you been able to explain it?
00:19:44PICARD: Not to my knowledge.
00:19:46We have.
00:19:51Our readings are quite clear about it.
00:19:54Information retrieved from the lab's ground computers indicate that a focused energy pulse was fired just as Commander Riker began transport.
00:20:03Furthermore, by analyzing the angle and trajectory, we have determined that it came from the very spot
00:20:09Commander Riker was standing.
00:20:17So then, will you allow me to show you my re-creation of the end of this story?
00:20:25A speculation, if you will.
00:20:27Computer... run hypothetical Krag one.
00:20:37Riker to Enterprise.
00:20:38I'm ready to leave now.
00:20:40O'BRIEN: Stand by, Commander.
00:20:42Engaging transport.
00:20:45KRAG: Freeze program.
00:20:47Three seconds later, the space station exploded.
00:21:07LA FORGE: The Tanugans are right.
00:21:09Something was fired at the reactor core just before transport.
00:21:12The energy signature would seem to indicate a phaser-like blast.
00:21:15Well, it wasn't the Commander's phaser.
00:21:17It couldn't have been.
00:21:18There's another answer.
00:21:20We're just not seeing it.
00:21:22Was there anything else in the lab capable of creating this kind of energy discharge?
00:21:26Not that I saw.
00:21:27Besides, how do you account for the fact that it came from Commander Riker's exact position?
00:21:31Damn it, I should've stayed with him.
00:21:33( beeping )
00:21:34Commander.
00:21:35Sensors indicate a radiation burst on deck 39 outside cargo bay 12.
00:21:39Source?
00:21:41Unknown, sir.
00:21:42Computer, identify type of radiation.
00:21:44Emission is not consistent with any known radiation.
00:21:49It is subsiding, sir.
00:21:53WESLEY: What kind of radiation could do this?
00:21:58Make any sense to you?
00:21:59I don't recognize it.
00:22:01Not even the main deflector puts out that kind of spillage.
00:22:04Where would it be coming from?
00:22:06I don't know, Wes, but whatever it is it's capable of putting a hole in solid duranium.
00:22:28In a sense, we have already met Mrs. Apgar, so we shall dispense with introductions.
00:22:35PICARD: Mrs. Apgar, you understand the purpose of this hearing?
00:22:39TROI: We understand how difficult this will be for you.
00:22:43If you need a recess, please don't hesitate to ask.
00:22:47PICARD: Would you like to make a statement before we begin?
00:22:51No.
00:22:52I just know he did it.
00:22:55He killed my husband.
00:22:59Computer, load Manua Simulation One.
00:23:06Run program.
00:23:07If you greet them with such a long face they're going to assume something is wrong with the experiment.
00:23:13I just need time, a little more time.
00:23:15I'm certain they'll give you all the time you need if you just show a little charm.
00:23:20You do that so much better than I do.
00:23:27Manua, someday I'll be able to reward you for all your patience.
00:23:33I'll get you everything you ever dreamed of.
00:23:35I have all the reward I need.
00:23:37Now go on.
00:23:39I'll be right in.
00:23:43( door opens and closes )
00:23:45RIKER: Dr. Apgar?
00:23:47I'm Commander William Riker.
00:23:49Lieutenant Commander Geordi La Forge.
00:23:51My assistant, Tayna.
00:23:53Well, let's get on with it, shall we?
00:23:56Don't be in such a hurry, dear.
00:23:57Perhaps our guests would like some refreshment?
00:24:00My wife, Manua.
00:24:02A pleasure to meet you, Manua.
00:24:04NEL: I'm anxious to get started.
00:24:06If you wish.
00:24:07I must say, I resent your early arrival, Commander.
00:24:09I have much work to do.
00:24:10Doctor, I'll do everything in my power to make this as painless as possible for both of us.
00:24:15Do you assist your husband in his work?
00:24:17Oh, dear, no, I'm no scientist.
00:24:19No, neither am I.
00:24:21But I find this all fascinating, don't you?
00:24:24Mr. La Forge, why don't you take a look at the Doctor's experimental data.
00:24:29Later you can give me an overview.
00:24:32Fine, whatever.
00:24:33Starfleet will get its Krieger-wave converter.
00:24:35These things take time.
00:24:36I've had a few setbacks, that's all.
00:24:38RIKER: Doctor, I'm not trying to put any pressure on you.
00:24:40I'm sure my report will only underscore the need for continued support of your research.
00:24:46Mm-hmm.
00:24:47Tayna,
00:24:49I'll call up the records.
00:24:51Show the Commander's assistant whatever he wants to see.
00:24:53Yes, Doctor. If you'll come with me.
00:24:55Our field generator is on the planet since it requires a minimum of 5,000 kilometers for the field to collimate.
00:25:03Darling, let Tayna take care of that.
00:25:05I'm sure Commander Riker wants to hear how close you are to a breakthrough.
00:25:09I'll pour the two of you a drink and you can talk all about Krieger waves.
00:25:21Commander.
00:25:24To success.
00:25:26Success.
00:25:29Well, in a way, I suppose it's good that you're early.
00:25:34Manua's right.
00:25:36It gives me a chance to show you the progress we've been making.
00:25:39I would appreciate it if Commander La Forge and I could stay here until the Enterprise returns.
00:25:46It's a little inconvenient.
00:25:47It would help to accelerate the process.
00:25:54Well, if you wish, Commander.
00:25:58Now, uh... where shall I start?
00:26:04Well, first of all, you should know that I am very close to being able to collimate a Krieger field.
00:26:16Our guest quarters are quite modest.
00:26:19RIKER: Very charming.
00:26:21It has your touch.
00:26:22The station is small and we don't often have guests, so I use this as my sanctuary.
00:26:27Who do you need sanctuary from?
00:26:30The environmental controls are here.
00:26:34( sighing )
00:26:36Commander, please... it's late and I'm tired.
00:26:40A man more interested in Krieger waves than a lovely woman like you...
00:26:43How is that possible?
00:26:44My husband is one of the greatest minds in the galaxy, and we love each other very much.
00:26:50Please, don't.
00:26:51RIKER: You must be very lonely... a princess in a very high tower.
00:26:56Please, my husband will be looking for me.
00:26:58Your sanctuary, remember?
00:27:00Commander, don't, please!
00:27:01She's lying.
00:27:02That never happened.
00:27:04Freeze program.
00:27:05Please...
00:27:07Captain, you know I would never act like that.
00:27:10Commander Riker...
00:27:12This isn't me.
00:27:13I wasn't the one who closed the door.
00:27:15I didn't proposition her and I certainly didn't try to rape her.
00:27:20Why are you doing this?
00:27:22It's exactly what happened.
00:27:26Will, come on, sit down.
00:27:43Resume program.
00:27:46Please...
00:27:48I knew you'd try this, Riker.
00:27:50Do you think I didn't notice how you looked at her?
00:27:53I'm not the fool you take me for.
00:27:59You won't get away with this.
00:28:02Your career is over.
00:28:04I'll see to it, I swear I will, Riker.
00:28:06If you report this, you'll be making a terrible mistake, Doctor.
00:28:10A terrible mistake.
00:28:18Freeze program.
00:28:22Your career was safe.
00:28:24He was a scientist.
00:28:27In another day, some fascinating bit of technical trivia would have distracted him.
00:28:31He would have forgotten about you and his complaint to Starfleet.
00:28:36( softly ): Excuse me.
00:28:42We'll, um... we'll take a short recess.
00:28:57Why would she lie like that?
00:29:00She was lying.
00:29:01You could tell.
00:29:03Will, I didn't sense any deception from her.
00:29:08Then you think that I would...?
00:29:10No! No, of course not.
00:29:12I know you.
00:29:13You don't have to convince me of anything.
00:29:15We can't both be telling the truth.
00:29:17It is the truth as each of you remembers it.
00:29:24But her version puts a noose around my neck.
00:29:31This is healing beautifully.
00:29:32I think you can work on strengthening those muscles again.
00:29:35WORF: Security to Dr. Crusher.
00:29:37( alarm blaring )
00:29:38Evacuate. Repeat, evacuate.
00:29:40Radiation emissions are indicated in Sick Bay.
00:29:42( alarm continues )
00:29:56This is definitely the same radiation that penetrated deck 39.
00:30:00Highly focused, very powerful, but of unknown origin.
00:30:02If this should happen near the engine core or the antimatter containment tanks, we'll be in big trouble, Captain.
00:30:08Do you have any theories?
00:30:10Captain, Data's noticed something that's too strange to be a coincidence.
00:30:14The two radiation events aboard the Enterprise occurred five hours, 20 minutes and three seconds apart.
00:30:19The science station exploded yesterday at almost four times that interval.
00:30:23WESLEY: There's a .0014-second variance we haven't been able to explain yet.
00:30:29So you're saying there's a connection between the radiation bursts and the explosion.
00:30:33We do not have the evidence to support that conclusion at this time, Commander.
00:30:36BEVERLY: If they're right, we should be able to predict the next event.
00:30:41We're expecting it in just over five hours.
00:30:42Well, take every precaution to protect the ship's vital areas.
00:30:46If we haven't identified the source before the next time interval, we'll leave orbit.
00:30:52If you perceive any further danger, advise me immediately.
00:30:58We'll figure it out for you, Commander.
00:31:12After the... the fight, Dr. Apgar came to find me.
00:31:16He was very upset.
00:31:20And he told you what happened?
00:31:22Yes, he told me everything that happened.
00:31:25Based on Tayna's deposition, we have re-created the incident in Commander Riker's quarters as Dr. Apgar described it to her.
00:31:33Computer...
00:31:34Inspector, Inspector, this is hearsay.
00:31:36She wasn't a witness to this incident.
00:31:39But Dr. Apgar is dead.
00:31:41Her statement is admissible according to Tanugan law and I insist you consider it.
00:31:50Well... we'll watch this "evidence" and we'll weigh it accordingly.
00:31:59Computer, run Tayna Simulation Three.
00:32:08I knew I'd find the two of you together.
00:32:11Do you think I didn't notice how you were looking at each other?
00:32:15I'm not the fool you take me for.
00:32:22I'm going to report this, Riker.
00:32:24You can count on that.
00:32:26You're a dead man, Apgar.
00:32:28A dead man.
00:32:30Freeze program.
00:32:32And then Dr. Apgar came to find you?
00:32:35Yes.
00:32:37Run Tayna Simulation Four.
00:32:43I want you to take Manua and beam down to Tanuga immediately.
00:32:47But, Doctor, if he threatened you you shouldn't stay.
00:32:50I'm not leaving him here alone.
00:32:51He's capable of anything.
00:32:53I've got to protect our work.
00:32:54I'll contact the authorities.
00:32:56No... I'll take care of that.
00:33:02Doctor, be careful.
00:33:05It'll be all right.
00:33:07Go on.
00:33:09KRAG: Freeze program.
00:33:12Then what happened?
00:33:13I left the station with Manua.
00:33:15The next day, when I heard the station had exploded,
00:33:19I knew what had happened.
00:33:21He'd killed Dr. Apgar.
00:33:23KRAG: Thank you.
00:33:26You are excused.
00:33:28( door opens and closes )
00:33:31Captain, I have established motive, method and opportunity.
00:33:36In any court in the Federation that is sufficient to warrant the extradition of the accused.
00:33:43I await your decision forthwith.
00:33:57I don't see any alternative.
00:33:59Do you?
00:34:00We both know Will's innocent.
00:34:02Of course he's innocent!
00:34:04But as a Starfleet Captain, I can't allow myself the luxury of yielding to personal feelings.
00:34:12The evidence warrants a trial.
00:34:14I'll have to allow extradition.
00:34:17Do you think there's enough evidence to prove his innocence?
00:34:24No.
00:34:25DATA: Captain, I believe we have found the source of the radiation.
00:34:29Can you join us on the Bridge?
00:34:31Acknowledged.
00:34:37As you know, Captain, we are looking for a phenomenon that reoccurs every five hours
00:34:4220 minutes and three seconds.
00:34:43The interval between the radiation bursts.
00:34:45We have found one such phenomenon on the planet surface.
00:34:48It's the field generator that Apgar used during his research.
00:34:51When it's fully charged it automatically emits an energy pulse and then takes five hours
00:34:5520 minutes and three seconds to recharge itself.
00:34:58It must have been left on after the explosion at the lab.
00:35:01But why would a generator be affecting the Enterprise in this way?
00:35:05It should not be.
00:35:06It is a harmless lambda field generator.
00:35:09LA FORGE: But we knew that somehow it was related to our radiation bursts, and then the pieces just started falling together.
00:35:14We now know what is causing the bursts and why the science station exploded, sir.
00:35:18And we also know who killed Dr. Apgar.
00:35:38Chief Inspector, we've watched these events replayed over and over again and... I am impressed and admittedly dismayed by the body of evidence against Commander Riker.
00:35:55But isn't it remarkable that with all the witnesses, all the different points of view of the events aboard the space station, we haven't seen what really happened?
00:36:08I do not understand.
00:36:10Allow me, with the help of Mr. La Forge, to explain.
00:36:14Computer, load Manua Program One, time index 14-4-1.
00:36:22Play program.
00:36:24Fine, whatever.
00:36:26Starfleet will get its Krieger-wave converter.
00:36:28These things take time.
00:36:29I've had a few setbacks, that's all.
00:36:31PICARD: Freeze.
00:36:33Mrs. Apgar, this is taken from your deposition.
00:36:35It would seem to suggest that your husband had failed to create Krieger waves.
00:36:39Yes, but he was very close to a breakthrough.
00:36:41He said he needed more time.
00:36:43He was upset by our early arrival.
00:36:45Where in fact, I maintain that he had already made that breakthrough and that he was lying to us.
00:36:53On what basis?
00:36:54LA FORGE: For the last several hours the Enterprise has been experiencing unusual radiation bursts.
00:36:59We've identified them as Krieger waves.
00:37:02Krieger waves?
00:37:03But that's impossible.
00:37:04From where?
00:37:05From right here inside the holodeck.
00:37:08PICARD: We have re-created your science lab in every conceivable detail.
00:37:12Essentially, what was in the original lab is here.
00:37:15Including the Krieger-wave converter that Dr. Apgar claimed didn't work, except it does work.
00:37:20Your field generator down on the planet surface has been sending out harmless energy charges, which this facsimile has been converting into Krieger waves.
00:37:31But the holodeck can't create anything dangerous.
00:37:33Well, it didn't.
00:37:35When you get down to basics, the converter is nothing more than a complex series of mirrors and reflective coils.
00:37:42The energy from the field generator down on the planet simply reflects off of elements in the converter, which turns it into highly focused Krieger waves.
00:37:52And those same waves have been randomly striking different areas of our ship as we orbit the planet and our angle to the generator changes.
00:38:00Why would Dr. Apgar lie about his success?
00:38:04Computer, run Manua Program One, time index 14-3-8.
00:38:11Manua, someday I'll be able to reward you for all your patience.
00:38:16I'll get you everything you ever dreamed of.
00:38:20I have all the reward I need.
00:38:23PICARD: Freeze program.
00:38:25Computer, run Riker Program Two, time index 16-1-0.
00:38:35To your success, Doctor.
00:38:37And the rewards that come with it.
00:38:40PICARD: Freeze.
00:38:42I never said that.
00:38:44Nevertheless, it seems clear that your husband was motivated to earn the rewards that pleased you,
00:38:49Mrs. Apgar.
00:38:51What's wrong with that?
00:38:52TROI: Well, he wouldn't have earned great profits from his dealings with Starfleet.
00:38:57We were only interested in a new power source.
00:38:59But if he could turn this into a weapon, it would be worth a lot to the Romulans, the Ferengi, and a few others.
00:39:05Now, Dr. Apgar had been ordering extra dicosilium for months.
00:39:08That's a pretty good indication that he was trying to create larger reflective coils.
00:39:11And when the away team arrived early, he must have been worried that Starfleet was becoming suspicious.
00:39:20He needed more time to finish his work.
00:39:22Apgar said that in each of the three versions.
00:39:25No doubt he was afraid that Commander Riker might learn the truth and cut off his support prematurely.
00:39:38Discovering Commander Riker with his wife didn't help matters.
00:39:43I submit he decided to murder Commander Riker.
00:39:46Ridiculous.
00:39:49Is it?
00:39:51Computer, run Tayna Program Four, time index 18-1-4.
00:40:01I'll contact the authorities.
00:40:04No... I'll take care of that.
00:40:09PICARD: Freeze.
00:40:12Tayna, what exactly is Apgar doing here?
00:40:14Activating the generator on the planet.
00:40:18Now, why would he do that?
00:40:20Maybe he was going to work on the converter.
00:40:23I don't know.
00:40:24Maybe he was already thinking ahead to his next confrontation with Commander Riker.
00:40:30Computer, play Riker Program Four, time index 24-1.
00:40:39What are you going to put in your report, Riker?
00:40:40That there's no justification for all the extra dicosilium I've requested?
00:40:44That is why they sent you early, isn't it?
00:40:46Doctor...
00:40:47I can explain why I needed it.
00:40:49They have no idea what my problems are.
00:40:51There are explanations for...
00:40:53I don't need explanations.
00:40:54PICARD: Freeze.
00:40:56To Apgar, this must have seemed as though
00:40:59Commander Riker were confirming his worst fears, and I believe it was now that he finally decided to kill him.
00:41:06KRAG: You forget, Picard.
00:41:08We know that the energy pulse which blew up the reactor originated from Commander Riker's position not Dr. Apgar's.
00:41:16Hmm... We are hypothesizing that Dr. Apgar energized the converter at the moment of Commander Riker's beam-out, hoping to make his death look like a transporter accident, but something went wrong.
00:41:28The energy pulse hit the transporter beam and reflected back to the reactor, which caused the explosion.
00:41:35An interesting hypothesis, but impossible to prove.
00:41:39LA FORGE: Not really.
00:41:41We know that field generator on the planet has been repeating a discharge ever since the explosion.
00:41:45The intervals are like clockwork
00:41:46except the explosion occurred
00:41:49.0014 seconds after the initial discharge.
00:41:53Now, the only explanation for that variance is the time it would take the energy pulse to bounce back from the transporter beam to the reactor.
00:42:00We've arranged a demonstration to illustrate.
00:42:02Mr. La Forge, I think it's about time, isn't it?
00:42:05Computer, load program La Forge One.
00:42:08Coordinate auto-engage time sequence.
00:42:11The next discharge from the field generator is scheduled to occur in just a few moments.
00:42:16Now, we've aligned the holodeck program to re-create the final events as Commander Riker described them, only this time, our facsimile will automatically process the energy charge from the planet and reflect it just as the original converter did before the explosion.
00:42:31If we're correct, we'll know it instantly.
00:42:35COMPUTER: Auto-engage time sequence synchronized.
00:42:39Then we have nothing further to say to each other.
00:42:43I'll tell my Captain to expect your grievance.
00:42:46Do that.
00:42:48Riker to Enterprise.
00:42:50I'm ready to leave now.
00:42:52O'BRIEN: Stand by, Commander.
00:42:53Engaging transport.
00:43:19Dr. Apgar killed himself during his attempt to kill Commander Riker.
00:43:31Based on this new evidence, I withdraw my request for Commander Riker's extradition.
00:43:38Commander... my apologies.
00:43:51Number One, have we any further business in the Tanuga system?
00:43:55None that I know of.
00:43:57I'd be more than willing to put it behind me.
00:43:58Then perhaps you would do me the pleasure of getting this ship underway.
00:44:01With pleasure, sir.
00:44:03Ensign Crusher, set course for Emila II, warp three.
00:44:08Course laid in, sir.
00:44:09Engage.